top of page
e224c7_76601aea3ab24218af052251ae03e478~mv2.png

🍟 Saving Great Movies From Rotten Scores 🍅

Because Sometimes Critics Get It Wrong

We're not afraid to say what everyone's thinking. Join us as we expose the most overrated films and defend the underrated gems that deserved better.

tomato_1f345.avif
tomato_1f345.avif

Tomato Scores

QUESTIONED

tomato_1f345.avif
french-fries_1f35f.png

Potato Scores

CORRECTED

Group 1.png

Saved from the Critics

Eternal Shadows

A haunting exploration of memory and loss that critics misunderstood.

Critics Say

tomato_1f345.avif
tomato_1f345.avif

42%

VS

We say

tomato_1f345.avif
french-fries_1f35f.png

89%

e224c7_8730cc1383af42cabc849cca44376e9d~mv2.png

Saved from the Critics

Focus

Focus follows veteran con artist Nicky and newcomer Jess, whose growing connection complicates a high-stakes scheme where trust is the most dangerous gamble.

Critics Say

tomato_1f345.avif
tomato_1f345.avif

55%

VS

We say

tomato_1f345.avif
french-fries_1f35f.png

80%

Trending This Week:

47842-jumper-0-230-0-345-crop.jpg

Action

Jumper

2008

tomato_1f345.avif

15%

french-fries_1f35f.png

55%

Do you agree with our score?

Icon.png

123

Icon (3).png

82

60% agree

47842-jumper-0-230-0-345-crop.jpg

Musical

The Phantom of the Opera

2005

tomato_1f345.avif

32%

french-fries_1f35f.png

82%

Do you agree with our score?

Icon.png

132

Icon (3).png

51

72% agree

47842-jumper-0-230-0-345-crop.jpg

Adventure

Hook

1991

tomato_1f345.avif

29%

french-fries_1f35f.png

72%

Do you agree with our score?

Icon.png

101

Icon (3).png

61

62% agree

47842-jumper-0-230-0-345-crop.jpg

Action

Sucker Punch

2011

tomato_1f345.avif

22%

french-fries_1f35f.png

60%

Do you agree with our score?

Icon.png

93

Icon (3).png

70

57% agree

47842-jumper-0-230-0-345-crop.jpg

Action

Book of Eli

2010

tomato_1f345.avif

46%

french-fries_1f35f.png

77%

Do you agree with our score?

Icon.png

141

Icon (3).png

60

70% agree

47842-jumper-0-230-0-345-crop.jpg

Comedy

Step Brothers

2008

tomato_1f345.avif

55%

french-fries_1f35f.png

88%

Do you agree with our score?

Icon.png

201

Icon (3).png

40

83% agree

CRITIC DISAGREEMENTS

Films we disagree with

Discover films where professional critics and real movie lovers see things differently

🍟 Critics overlooked, we paid attention

47842-jumper-0-230-0-345-crop.jpg

Sci-Fi

In Time

2011

tomato_1f345.avif

36%

french-fries_1f35f.png

83%

Do you agree with our score?

Icon.png

165

Icon (3).png

40

80% agree

47842-jumper-0-230-0-345-crop.jpg

Horror

Saw

2004

tomato_1f345.avif

50%

french-fries_1f35f.png

91%

Do you agree with our score?

Icon.png

193

Icon (3).png

31

86% agree

47842-jumper-0-230-0-345-crop.jpg

Fantasy

Twilight

2008

tomato_1f345.avif

48%

french-fries_1f35f.png

87%

Do you agree with our score?

Icon.png

151

Icon (3).png

72

68% agree

47842-jumper-0-230-0-345-crop.jpg

Martial Art

Kung Pow

2002

tomato_1f345.avif

13%

french-fries_1f35f.png

65%

Do you agree with our score?

Icon.png

111

Icon (3).png

90

55% agree

Join the Movement

Have a Rating the Critics Got Wrong?

Submit your movie for review and help us expose more unjust ratings

CRITICS

Their Score

SPUDS

Your Score

We review all submissions and add the best ones to our collection

500+

Movies Reviewed

50K+

Spud Squad Members

1M+

Votes Cast

Untitled design (3).png
Parody Disclaimer:

Rotton Potatos is a parody website created for entertainment purposes. All movie scores, reviews, and ratings are fictional and meant for fun. We have the utmost respect for film critics and their work. This site is not affiliated with or endorsed by Rotten Tomatoes or any movie review platform. Enjoy responsibly! 🎬🍟

LINKS

Home
Submit a Review

DESIGNERS SOCIALS

TikTok



Instagram



Youtube

STAY CONNECTED

Get the latest news & updates

© 2026 Rotten Potatoes

Designed with ♥️ by Taylor Zipp

bottom of page